Skip to content

Human Factor Podcast Season 3 Episode 036: The Misread – Why Structural Friction Gets Read As Individual Resistance

Season 3, Episode 036

The Misread – Why Structural Friction Gets Read As Individual Resistance

With Jenny Vazquez-Newsum, Founder and CEO of Untapped Leaders and Author of Untapped Leadership


Host: Kevin Novak


Guest: Jenny Vazquez-Newsum


Duration: 61 minutes


Available: October 8, 2026

🎙️Season 3, Episode 36

Episodes are available in both video and audio formats across all major podcast platforms, including Spotify, YouTube, Pandora, Apple Podcasts, and via RSS, among others.

Transcript Available Below

Episode Overview

The Misread – Why Structural Friction Gets Read As Individual Resistance

Season 3 | Guest Episode with Jenny Vazquez-Newsum

Somewhere in your organization right now, there is an initiative that is not landing. Adoption is thinner than the plan said it would be. The middle of the building has gone quiet. The people you were counting on are asking a lot of procedural questions and almost no enthusiastic ones. So a meeting gets called, and in that meeting somebody says the word: resistance. Or they say it more gently. Change fatigue. A communication problem. Not everyone is bought in yet. With one word, the problem moved. It stopped being something about the organization and became something about the people inside it, and the fix followed the diagnosis: more training, better messaging, a session on adaptability and resilience. What almost nobody says in that meeting is that the conditions those people are working inside would produce exactly this behavior from anyone, including everyone in the room.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum has spent two decades on that gap, and she arrives from a direction this show has not had before. She came up through Coro Southern California, the civic leadership institute whose cohorts put public, private, labor, and nonprofit leaders in the same room, arguing, where she served as vice president of leadership training and programs. By her own count she has worked with more than 500 leaders across more than 200 organizations, from executives at large corporations to high school students at the beginning of the whole thing. She holds a doctorate in education from UCLA, a Master of Public Administration from NYU, and a business degree from USC. In 2023 she published Untapped Leadership, which argued that a great deal of leadership capacity sits in places organizations do not look. Then she built a method. It is called contextual agility: the capacity to assess an environment, understand its history and nuance, and choose leadership responses that fit the moment rather than relying on habit, impulse, or universal formula. It runs on four lenses: lived insight, systems thinking, personal agency, and shared vision.

The conversation starts where her work starts, which is almost never at the beginning. By the time somebody calls her, the organization has usually already decided what is wrong, and the decision has almost always been made about people. Kevin sets Lee Ross’s fundamental attribution error next to that habit, and Jenny answers with the rule her interventions are built on: no challenge is just a people challenge, it is also a systems challenge, and the intervention has to be designed for what happens the Monday after the training. From there, with Edgar Schein on the assumptions nobody in the building can articulate anymore and Dorothy Leonard-Barton on core capabilities that are also core rigidities, Jenny walks through one reading: the regional philanthropic organization that hired her to fix hiring and onboarding and found the larger question of what allows anyone to succeed there. Then the practical questions an executive listening will want answered. How far back does the history go, how do you find it when nobody will tell you, how long does an honest reading take (about six weeks), and what she is solving for when leaders reach for what Kevin calls uninformed urgency.

The middle of the episode is about the four lenses and about whose reading counts. Kevin brings Donella Meadows and Jay Forrester on leverage points found and pushed in the wrong direction, and a hypothesis: personal agency applied before systems thinking is resilience training offered as the answer to a structural problem. Jenny’s answer is that the lenses are not a sequence at all. The leadership challenge is holding all four at once, and every leader has a default lens that, overused, hides something else. Then structural silence, with Patricia Hill Collins on the outsider within, Karl Weick and Kathleen Sutcliffe on deference to expertise, and Tangirala and Ramanujam on procedural justice climate, and Jenny’s elephant: the cartoon of experts in lab coats examining a tail, a hoof, a tusk, and calling each one something else, while the person standing at the margins says, that is an elephant. All of us, somewhere, are too close to one, and the higher you sit in an organization, the closer you are. It is the position, not the person.

The last stretch is measurement and AI. Jenny opens up the Untapped Capacity Index, the diagnostic from her 2025 impact report: what it asks, what it returns, and the finding that has been consistent across every organization that has taken it, that systems thinking comes back lowest, because those are the prompts that ask about power. Kevin brings Robert Austin and Peter Blau on dysfunction and asks how an index of the system avoids becoming one more thing the system learns to produce. Then what a framework built on reading conditions does when the reading is increasingly done by something that cannot read, the 48-hour decision and the minimum viable reading of a system, and the reflection question this season asks every guest. Jenny’s answer is the assumption she most wants leaders to stop making: that the people experiencing the problem do not have the answers.

About Jenny Vazquez-Newsum

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum, Ed.D., is the founder and CEO of Untapped Leaders and the author of Untapped Leadership: Harnessing the Power of Underrepresented Leaders (Prometheus, 2023). She came up through Coro Southern California, where she served as vice president of leadership training and programs, building and facilitating cross-sector leadership programs for years, and by her own count has worked with more than 500 leaders across more than 200 organizations, from executives at large corporations to high school students. She holds a doctorate in education from UCLA, a Master of Public Administration from NYU, and a business degree from USC. Her method, contextual agility, runs on four lenses (lived insight, systems thinking, personal agency, and shared vision) and underpins the Untapped Capacity Index, the diagnostic introduced in the Untapped Leaders 2025 impact report. She is based in Los Angeles. Find her at untappedleaders.com and jennyv-n.com.

Resources

Untapped Leaders (untappedleaders.com)

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum (jennyv-n.com)

Untapped Leadership: Harnessing the Power of Underrepresented Leaders (Amazon)

Untapped Leaders 2025 Impact Report, introducing the Untapped Capacity Index (PDF)

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum on LinkedIn

Episode 032: The Measurement Ratchet, the Season 3 Opener

Episode 035: The Missing Half of Change Management, with Dr Grant Van Ulbrich

Subscribe to the Ideas and Innovations Newsletter (It’s free)

The Truth About Transformation: Leading in the Age of AI, Uncertainty and Human Complexity (Book)

Research Referenced in This Episode

Ross, L. (1977). The Intuitive Psychologist and His Shortcomings: Distortions in the Attribution Process. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 10. Academic Press.
Schein, E.H. (2013). Humble Inquiry: The Gentle Art of Asking Instead of Telling. Berrett-Koehler. (With Schein’s layered model of culture from Organizational Culture and Leadership, Jossey-Bass, 1985.)
Leonard-Barton, D. (1992). Core Capabilities and Core Rigidities: A Paradox in Managing New Product Development. Strategic Management Journal, 13(S1).
Meadows, D.H. (1999). Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System. The Sustainability Institute. (Including the account of Jay Forrester’s observation about leverage points pushed in the wrong direction.)
Collins, P.H. (1986). Learning from the Outsider Within: The Sociological Significance of Black Feminist Thought. Social Problems, 33(6).
Weick, K.E., and Sutcliffe, K.M. (2007). Managing the Unexpected: Resilient Performance in an Age of Uncertainty (2nd ed.). Jossey-Bass.
Tangirala, S., and Ramanujam, R. (2008). Employee Silence on Critical Work Issues: The Cross Level Effects of Procedural Justice Climate. Personnel Psychology, 61(1).
Austin, R.D. (1996). Measuring and Managing Performance in Organizations. Dorset House. (Building on Peter Blau’s definition of dysfunction in The Dynamics of Bureaucracy, University of Chicago Press, 1955.)
Vazquez-Newsum, J. (2023). Untapped Leadership: Harnessing the Power of Underrepresented Leaders. Prometheus.
Untapped Leaders (2025). 2025 Impact Report, introducing the Untapped Capacity Index.

Key Takeaways

1

No Challenge Is Just a People Challenge. It Is Also a Systems Challenge, and the Intervention Has to Be Built for the Monday After the Training

2

The First Diagnosis Is Rarely Wrong. It Is Rarely Deep Enough. Trust Is Built or Eroded by the Design of How the Work Gets Done

3

The Present Moment Is Being Informed by the Past. History Is Not Background. It Is a Mechanism, and Somebody Has to Ask About It

4

The Four Lenses Are Not a Sequence. Personal Agency Applied Before Systems Thinking Is Resilience Training Offered as the Answer to a Structural Problem

5

All of Us Are Too Close to an Elephant Somewhere. The Higher You Sit, the Closer You Are, and It Is the Nature of the Position, Not a Verdict on the Person

6

Systems Thinking Comes Back Lowest on the Index, Consistently, Because Those Are the Prompts That Ask About Power

7

The Minimum Viable Reading Fits in a Pause: Who Is Closest to the Consequences, Who Is Shaping the Response, What Happens in the System, Who Is Left Out, and How Does It Connect to the Vision

8

Stop Assuming the People Experiencing the Problem Do Not Have the Answers. The Leader-as-Hero Mentality Is the Misread in Its Purest Form

Season 3, Episode 36 Transcript

Available October 8, 2026

Episode 036: The Misread – Why Structural Friction Gets Read As Individual Resistance

DURATION: 61 minutes
HOST: Kevin Novak
GUEST: Jenny Vazquez-Newsum, Founder and CEO of Untapped Leaders and Author of Untapped Leadership
FORMAT: Guest Conversation
SHOW: The Human Factor Podcast

COLD OPEN

Kevin Novak: Somewhere in your organization right now, there’s an initiative that isn’t landing. Adoption is thinner than the plan said it would be. The middle of the building, well, they’ve gone quiet. The people that you were counting on are asking a lot of procedural questions and almost no enthusiastic ones. So a meeting gets called. And in that meeting, somebody says the word. Resistance. Or they say it more gently. Maybe change fatigue. A communication problem. Not everyone is brought in yet. Notice what just happened. With one word, the problem moved. It stopped being something about the organization, and it became something about the people inside of it. And the fix? Well, it follows the diagnosis. Every time. More training, better messaging, a session on adaptability and resilience. Here’s what almost nobody says in that meeting: that the conditions those people are working inside would produce exactly this behavior from anyone, including everyone in this room. Today’s guest, she has spent two decades on that gap. And she has built a method for reading the conditions before the answer gets chosen.

INTRODUCTION

Kevin Novak: I’m Kevin Novak, CEO of 2040 Digital, professor at the University of Maryland, and author of the book The Truth About Transformation: Leading in the Age of AI, Uncertainty, and Human Complexity, along with the Ideas and Innovations weekly newsletter. Welcome to the Human Factor Podcast, the show that explores the intersection of humanity, technology, and transformation, along with the psychology behind transformation success. This is Season 3, the season all about practice. Season 1 was about seeing the human factor clearly. Season 2 was about what you do once you can see it. This season is about building it into how an organization works so that it lasts after the consultant leaves and the sponsor moves on. Two threads anchor this season: the dynamic between artificial intelligence and human beings, and measurement, because what you measure determines what you manage every time. Today’s guest. Well, she sits on both and she arrives from a direction this show hasn’t really had before. Jenny Vazquez-Newsum came up through Coro Southern California, the Civic Leadership Institute, where she served as vice president of leadership training and programs. Coro’s model is cross-sector by design. Public, private, labor, nonprofit, in the same cohort, in the same room, arguing. She built and facilitated those programs for years. By your own count, she has worked with more than 500 leaders across more than 200 organizations, from executives at large corporations to high school students at the beginning of the whole thing. She holds a doctorate in education from UCLA, a Master of Public Administration from NYU, and a business degree from USC. In 2023, she published Untapped Leadership, which argued that a great deal of leadership capacity sits in places organizations don’t look. And then she did something interesting, more interesting than writing a book. She built a method. It’s called contextual agility, and she defines it as the capacity to assess an environment, understand its history and nuance, and choose leadership responses that fit the moment rather than relying on habit, impulse, or universal formula, behaviors that happen far too often. Her method runs on four lenses: lived insight, systems thinking, personal agency, and shared vision. Season 2 of this show ended on three findings. And the second one was that structure beats intention. If you want different behavior, you usually have to change the structure before you can change the people. And most organizations, well, they attempt it in the reverse order, and then they blame the people. I got to that through organizational research and a couple hundred engagements. Jenny got there through facilitation and doctoral work on people leading inside constraints that they didn’t set. Two routes, one finding. Where I have mostly written about why the misreading happens, she has built a way to catch it. She is the founder and CEO of Untapped Leaders. And she has built a diagnostic instrument that I don’t believe she has ever discussed at this depth as we will today. Jenny, welcome to the Human Factor Podcast.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: So good to be here, Kevin. I’m so excited.

SEGMENT 1: WHAT IS UNDERNEATH A PEOPLE PROBLEM

Kevin Novak: I’m so happy to have you. I love your energy. So, Jenny, I want to start where your work actually starts, which is almost never at the beginning. And by the time somebody calls you, the organization has usually already decided on what’s wrong. And in my experience, the decision has almost always been made about people. So morale, resistance. A team that won’t get on board, and a leader who always needs to communicate better. So here’s the research that I want to put next to that. In 1977, a Stanford psychologist named Lee Ross published a chapter in a series called Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. He was describing what he called the intuitive psychologist, the ordinary person doing amateur social science all day long. And he named a pattern and how we do it. So when we watch another person’s behavior, we systematically overweight what we assume about the person and we underweight the situation that they’re standing in. And he called it the fundamental attribution error. So I’ll say it plainly that the construct has been argued about for 50 years since. I’m one of the fans of it because I believe people are very judgmental at times. And the shape of it is hard to unsee though, once you’ve seen it. Because that is exactly what a leadership team does when a rollout stalls. It looks at the behavior and reaches for a property of the people, somebody to put their finger to. So tell me what you actually find. When an organization hands you a people problem, what is underneath it?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yes. Because that is, you’re exactly right. My challenge and the work that I push organizations to explore is that no challenge is just a people challenge it’s also a systems challenge so all the interventions that I design and partner with organizations around are people plus systems interventions. So that when we do a facilitated training, let’s say we do kind of an intervention for the people, we’re also looking at what can happen the Monday after when they go back to implement what they’ve learned. And a lot of times the systems, the conditions are not conducive to folks actually putting forward the capacity that they’ve just built.

Kevin Novak: So in that regard, I’m in your camp and I see those things and I think people whether it’s the fear of not recognizing the humanness that’s in the room, about the people and the systems that were built that then are really the construct of underperformance or challenges or so forth. So when you go in, what do you look for as the tells? And in the first days of an engagement, what are you looking at that tells you the diagnosis in the room is wrong? They’ve diagnosed themselves incorrectly.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yeah. I’ll take that in a particular direction because I do think that folks have a good sense of an initial diagnosis, like say there is that a team culture challenge. Folks aren’t communicating, there’s low trust in an environment, and that’s a trust conversations are one I have often. And so they’re not wrong. The trust is not there. There needs to be some work around that. But, what I just know from doing this work for many years, there are conditions that either build or erode trust within the organization. And so as we have these conversations around trust, when I have those with a team, I have them explicitly identify what in there. Processes, in their rhythms, in their feedback cycles and in these parts that hold up the organization that are more systematic. Where is there, can you pinpoint, can you diagnose where trust is challenged just by the design of how you’re doing the work? I use that as an example that there’s usually these moments where people can pick up on a challenge and they’re not they’re not wrong, but it’s deeper a lot of times.

SEGMENT 2: HISTORY AS A MECHANISM

Kevin Novak: So I’m gonna dive a bit more into the practice and later I have tons of questions for you about the method and everything. And two more pieces of research to sort of set this up. And these are ones that I’m huge fans of. So the first is Edgar Schein, who spent a career arguing that culture has layers. And it’s what you can see, what the organization says it believes. And underneath both, assumptions that are so basic that nobody in the building can really articulate them anymore. And that’s part of what I wanna get with you later with the history. Because they’ve stopped being opinions and they’ve really become the water in the building. So late in his life, Schein wrote a small book called Humble Inquiry, subtitled The Gentle Art of Asking Instead of Telling. And his argument was that we are a telling culture and that status differences systematically shut down the upward information that complex work actually depends on. The senior person in the room is often left to be the last to find out, which we see tons. So the second is Dorothy Leonard-Barton, writing in Strategic Management Journal in 1992. She studied 20 development projects across five firms and found something more uncomfortable than the usual story about companies getting stuck. She found that core capability and core rigidities are the same thing seen from two different angles. So the precise attributes that make a firm excellent at its traditional work are what disables it completely on work that requires a different approach. And I have no doubt that’s happening over and over again in organizations. So you can’t surgically remove the rigidity. It’s the flip side of the excellence, right? So which means the history is not background. It’s really becomes a mechanism. So walk me through one reading. Whatever level of disguise that you need, what did you look at first? And just as importantly, what did you deliberately ignore?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yeah. And I have to echo that research it really resonates. And so I appreciate the you bringing it into this conversation. I’ll give an example. So for instance, I worked with a regional philanthropic organization here in LA, and I was brought in to examine their hiring and onboarding processes. The COO felt like they could do better with that process. Like there was something, they had a recent hire that didn’t quite pan out. And there was something that could improve, but they didn’t quite know what. So when I went in to do that work, I’m I’m evaluating context around both the individuals, the people that are there, the people that are doing the hiring, the people that are making the evaluations, the COO and that piece of it, but then also the systems piece of it, looking at the context of prior processes and also looking at what the hopes are, where they’re trying to move towards. And through that work, and it really kind of begins with kind of that diagnostic evaluation and exploration through engaging with the multiple stakeholders through that process. I found that, while we’re looking only just at hiring and onboarding, what ended up happening was this exploration of the larger culture at the organization and its opportunity to define what allows someone to succeed there, to get very clear of what that means for that organization, for their values. And then creating the systems where I learned that they have a very strong relational culture. And a lot of times hiring managers had a lot of agency, had a lot of ownership, were able to carry the work of hiring and onboarding, but there was no interconnected system for that. There was no architecture just yet around that part of the work.

Kevin Novak: So and building on that, because I’m with you, I’m a fan of context is everything. And to your point, context is incredibly complex. And sometimes there’s things that get missed. And so your own definition says to understand an environment’s history and nuance. History is the word doing the heaviest lifting in that sentence. So how far back do you go? And how do you find it when nobody in the building is willing to tell you?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yes, and that’s a great question. And I think it’s absolutely the most difficult to uncover. So there is this level of like say I’ve say I’m working with an organizational client and we’re looking at history. There is some kind of very, top level elements of that of looking at prior transitions. Prior documentation, you know, like what has been the almost the living history of those that are there in the room. So there is this element of like the project itself will kind of give us cues into how far back we need to go. But then also I think with the deeper work that I do around Untapped Leadership and really kind of think about the historical context of how many have been excluded from kind of the narrative of what leadership is and how we define it. I wrote the book from the perspectives and insights of underrepresented leaders. And so I hold this even longer historical context in my brain of sometimes thinking of like, well, I think that is inherited leadership norm that. Those are hard conversations. And it’s harder to pinpoint and it’s harder to name, but it’s not, I don’t want to ever be divorced from that as kind of I’m kind of doing the these conversations and the that exploration. So yeah, to answer the question, there is like the practical piece of it that I want to just make sure organizations know that the present moment is being informed by the past. We can’t take it as like a situation right now. There are these elements that are fueling the decisions, whatever’s happening in the moment, it is coming from some historical context. And I think again the challenge, and as you name, like if no one is aware of that, or if no one is naming that, I find it to be my job just to ask questions, just to explore and to see so that exploration does come into the space. So we never are doing anything where that is not involved, that history is involved.

Kevin Novak: So one question I want to ask because it gets to the practical element that you hit on. So you know if an executive’s listening and are thinking, I love Jenny, I want to get her in to help me. So how long does an honest reading actually take?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Hmm. Yeah. I think and this is where, some choice has to happen in this because usually, so what I do, particularly in the diagnostic piece of the work, it comes through multiple inputs of perspectives of stakeholders. So that would be C-suite. Those doing the work, whatever combination that sits around what we’re looking at. And so those are, I have a qualitative researcher by background. So those are qualitative conversations where I build that data. Yeah, but I think, again, thinking about the nuance of context, I think qualitative work hits on that. And I start to kind of build those threads. And coupled with some of the artifact assessments, like evaluation of artifacts that sit with the organization that I whether or not they’re practiced or you know utilized is a different story, but they’re they’re present. And so for a diagnostic engagement, that’s usually six weeks or so. It’s not it’s not this big long thing. So it could be fairly fast in a general sense. We don’t need to go so deep. Usually what I find is that the challenge, the roots of the challenge start to kind of rise up because it’s said from different angles and we’ve got it. We’re there. The one caveat I always name though is that context is always changing. We’re we’re building a muscle here to diagnose right now. To respond to right now, to build architecture around right now, and to build architecture in a way that is malleable. I think we’re just living in an era where things are changing very quickly. That’s not gonna change the urgency that leaders are experiencing is very real. I don’t want to discount that speed that sometimes is needed. But what I caution against is like the speed. That is maybe in not the right direction or, speed that kind of runs over some insights that actually could have got us there faster. Then that’s really what I’m trying to solve for.

Kevin Novak: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, I call it uninformed urgency.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Uninformed or I love that. Yep. Uninformed urgency. Yeah. So

Kevin Novak: Yeah, I write I’ve I’ve written a lot of articles about that because I do think that that urgency that they feel begets action and it’s often not with some deep thinking for the right decision and to your quantitative and qualitative point, understanding what information they need to better inform that urgency. So your four lenses are usually presented a as a set, right? So lived insights, systems thinking, personal agency, and shared vision, which is one of my favorites. So I’m curious whether they are also a sequence and what happens when a leader runs them out of order. So here’s why I think order matters, right? And I’m gonna explore that with you. And it comes from systems work rather than leadership work. And in 1999, Donella Meadows wrote a paper called Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System. So she ranked 12 places, and I grabbed this a long time ago because I was struggling with a project. So she ranked 12 places that you can push on a system from the weakest to the most powerful. And she relays a story from her teacher, Jay Forrester at MIT, that I have never been able to forget since I dove into this. Forrester said that people know intuitively where the leverage points are. So he would analyze an organization, identify the leverage points, go in and discover that everyone was already paying enormous attention to exactly that spot. And pushing it in his words and in the wrong direction and to our to what we were just talking about. So here’s a hypothesis, and I want you to correct it if it’s if it’s wrong or out of context. So when personal agency gets applied before systems thinking, you get resilience training offered as the answer to a structural problem. And the organization has correctly identified that something is happening to its people. And then it responds by asking those people to absorb it better rather than changing what they’re being asked to absorb. So right leverage point, you know, wrong decision and direction. So does that hold and which lens do leaders want to skip most often?

SEGMENT 3: THE FOUR LENSES, IN AND OUT OF ORDER

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yes. Yes. So that resonates. I’ll say to answer the first question. So we have the four lenses. They’re they’re not sequential. So the exercise is and why I can call it contextual agility, is Because we want to be able to say we have a challenge. You know, again, resilience or you know, really kind of folks kind of just doing the work and being motivated around it. We hold that. We want to be able to understand the lived insights of those folks, the systems piece, absolutely, but then the personal agency, what they think is possible within their realm of influence. And then ultimately the shared vision. What are we all here for? What are what is this effort for? And so the it might be that the the there’s motivation to use them sequentially. But I think that gets to your the challenge that you pose, that we will then go to doing work around personal agency. Like let’s say, we okay, we’ll equip our middle managers to be able to give feedback effectively. I’m like just using a tool as an example. And that’s what and we’ll we’ll strengthen our teams in this way. Well, the middle managers in the system are they’re, highly compressed in their roles. They are told they have authority, but they actually don’t. There’s all these kind of power questions that are happening. And so a leader might want to say, okay, let’s think about these sequentially, but it’s actually all of it at one time is the leadership challenge. And that’s really what I work with organizations around is how do we hold all of these. So we are then responding to a challenge like that, looking at role design, in addition to offering capacity building tools for leaders.

Kevin Novak: Yeah, well, what do you see leaders try to default to most often? Because I and the reason I’m asking that is because people get so stovepiped sometimes in wanting to solve a problem that they’re to your earlier point, so they’re gonna go after it. Okay, this is the this people issue, this is the systems issue without recognizing the context that surrounds it.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: So part of the work I do early with leaders, and I’ll I’ll use yesterday’s leadership retreat as an example, is have every individual leader look at the lenses and actually identify what their default lens is. I think we all have a default lens. So some folks will look at past experience, some folks will look systems and say look at the interconnectedness of what’s happening. Some folks go action, personal agency, like, let’s go. We have to, I can I can do something about this. I’m going to do something about this. And then some people think big picture, think about the bigger vision. And so it’s good to know where we like where we look first. I’m a systems thinker, as clearly, as I talk about this. So I look systems first. But then what we need to think about is when a lens is overused, there’s risk for that. And so I you know, to answer that question, I think every leader will be kind of thinking in a different way. The caution is like if I’m overusing that lens, I’m then missing something else. So I’ll use myself as an example. I think in a moment of pressure, of uncertainty, of like challenge, I think systems. So I look at all the things that are informing what this what’s happening with that challenge. Well, if I do that too much, I lose, and I have in the past, when I’ve we’ve kind of worked in organizations, sometimes I’ll lose my personal agency in that. I think this is too big. There’s nothing I can do. What can I do from where I sit? You know, like you start to have those and you know, those conversations with yourself. And so then I’ve I’ve overused a lens. And so that’s really kind of the exercise.

SEGMENT 4: WHOSE READING COUNTS AS DATA

Kevin Novak: Jenny, what you do is so important because and I did an episode last season about structural silence. And I wrote an article about that as well. And my point there was the context and the structure of the organization and the way the leadership is working is often keeping people quiet. And so they’re not thinking, they’re not speaking up, they’re not informing. Of what that reality is. And so I want to explore with you. So every organization runs on an unwritten rule about whose account of reality gets treated as data and whose gets treated as that attitude. And again, to my point, sometimes that’s created by leadership itself. So two people describe the same problem. One is taken as a finding. The other is taken as a bad attitude in the meeting. And the difference is very rarely the accuracy of the description. So there’s a serious body of work behind this. And I want to bring three pieces to it. In 1986, the sociologist Patricia Hill Collins published an essay in Social Problems. Called Learning from the Outsider Within. And consultants, I believe, are those people that a lot of people can learn from. Her argument is precise and is more specific than the way it usually gets repeated. So she’s describing a structural position, and it’s not a feeling. People who are granted intimate proximity to a dominant group’s inner life without ever being granted membership in it. And her claim this particular location produces a distinctive angle of vision and that the knowledge it generates has something to teach the discipline that produces it. And then one of my other favorites, Karl Weick and Kathleen Sutcliffe studying high reliability organizations. So aircraft carriers, nuclear plants, and firefighting crews name five principles organizations live by. One of them is deference to expertise, and the part people miss is the direction. In a high tempo event, decision authority migrates to whoever actually has the relevant knowledge, explicitly, including going downward, firemen on the ground. To people with no rank at all, right? So then it migrates back when the event ends. And it’s not flattening the org chart. It’s suspending it briefly for a distinct purpose. And then another piece of research on Personnel Psychology in 2008 studied 606 nurses across 30 work groups and found that whether an individual’s commitment and identification actually turned into speaking up depended on the procedural justice climate of their unit. Same person, different unit, different behaviors. So this is completely your territory more than mine. And it’s also where your book and the current framework kind of meet. And Untapped Leadership locates several of these capacities and the experience of people who have had to read systems accurately in order to operate inside of them. And your framework as it stands now presents contextual agility as a general leadership capability described through four lenses. And so both of those feel really true to me. And I’d like to understand what you learned about the in between. Does standpoint produce more accurate reading of a system, or is reading systems well a capability anyone can build with the right method?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: I’ll share a visual just to kind of bring it together. It’s something I share with groups when I’m kind of trying to explore a version of this of like what how standpoint affects how we understand what’s happening in systems. There’s a visual, it’s kind of a cartoon visual of a big elephant. And I don’t know you might have seen this, but there are a ton of folks that happen to be in white lab coats, looking really close at the elephant at all different parts of it and saying, this is a rug, this is a plant, whatever it may be, all these wrong things. It’s at the tail, it’s at the hoof, at the tusk, all these incorrect assessments of what that is. The work that I am trying to put forward, or at least the idea that I’m trying to put forward, especially with Untapped Leadership and kind of harnessing the power of underrepresented leaders and the work I did doing that research with the that group and writing that book is when you’re on the margins, when you are experiencing a system in some way on the margins, you are standing back and you’re like. That’s an elephant. What are you talking about? That I see you can see the elephant because you are in some way marginalized. The work I’ve done has of course focused on racial marginalization, but marginalization can happen a lot of different ways. It could happen in the hierarchy of an organization. It could happen on yeah, tenure, you know, expertise, as you mentioned, all these ways. And so what I try to kind of share with whoever I’m presenting that image to. Is that there is somewhere where we are, all of us, too close to an elephant. That let’s just take that as a fact. We there are some places that our view of a system is very close. It’s myopic because it is what we experience. Now it’s not that it’s not important, but if we’re not exercising and being intentional again around making sure either we find, what that the margins are in experience. We might have it that experience ourselves, or we’re making sure we’re bringing in the context that others have so that if I’m in a position of authority and I’m making a decision on behalf of, others, I am doing so from a better understanding of context, a better understanding of seeing an elephant so that I can make a decision that. That lands or that fits, or you know, or, you know, I again empathize with the leaders that have to make very tough decisions and very tough choices. I don’t think those are gonna go away. What I do want is that leaders are then aware of the tough choices they’re making and the impact that may have in other places. I think what I caution against is making tough choices and you know, being very close to an elephant while you’re making those choices and not even having awareness that you’re missing the book.

Kevin Novak: So how do people react when you bring up the elephant?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: They react well because I think folks can see it. I think my I just my after years of facilitating a lot of different types of spaces and a lot of different, levels of openness to the work, I try to find ways that are accessible to kind of say a challenging thing. And also kind of say a little bit of like the collective experience around that. So I do put a little bit more pressure on those in executive levels and then kind of positions of authority because of the power that’s held there. And so I really am direct in saying you’re by the nature of where you sit in an organization, you are very close to an elephant in a lot of ways. You will have big picture like awareness of a lot of different functions in your organization, that is an important perspective, but just humbly know that just by the positionality of where you sit, your view may be warped. How do you widen that? I find that folks are open to it when they realize it’s the nature of a position, and not a personal. Attack, a personal, affront on their leadership.

Kevin Novak: Have you seen because you work across so many leaders where that comes as a surprise to them? That they’re so close to the elephant that there are things that they haven’t seen or been told for that matter.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yeah, I see a range. And I think it also again depends on the level of self work a leader has done. I mean, I always, again, fundamentally think self awareness is like step one for effective leadership. And so, you know, I think folks will meet this conversation at the place where they’re at in their own world. So I do think that for to I’ll be frank, for folks that have not done it and are the leaders and are the they’re probably not calling me in to have the conversation. To be honest. And so this kind of that resistance is early. It’s felt early in

Kevin Novak: Jenny, this is probably gonna be a quick question for you, but so what determines whose reading gets received as data, right? And so if somebody does step away from the elephant, so it does it become rank, is it tenure, because you’ve mentioned these, or proximity to revenue or something that’s less obvious in your experience?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: I think what is important, or I think, what I try to design into the work is how the varied perspectives are valued. And that can of course be challenging dependent on again where power sits within an organization, I navigate those realities with the same contextual awareness that I’m I’m kind of be having organizations do. I think anywhere where the almost like the buck stops with the person at the top, I land at a place where I just want to make sure you know that is what’s happening and that this is kind of left out. These other insights are not you’re you’re confirming that these insights are not going to be part of how the solution is designed. Naming it is my first attempt to kind of shifting it so that I don’t want I wouldn’t want leaders to be operating again on autopilot or on assumptions that what they know that they know best. And so at as much as we are through the design of the process bringing in the insights of all these other perspectives, ultimately we’ll be landing on a choice, whatever it made a design choice, whatever an intervention choice. How much that leader or that person that has the actual authority to implement something adopts those insights, is it will ultimately be a choice. But I want that choice to be explicit,

SEGMENT 5: THE UNTAPPED CAPACITY INDEX AND MEASUREMENT

Kevin Novak: Jenny, I want to dive into your 2025 impact report because it names it brings forward the Untapped Capacity Index. And you described it as a diagnostic that surfaces strengths, system gaps, and the decision patterns that are shaping performance. So, what does it actually measure? Because one of the major themes is about measurement and measuring what matters. And so, what does it measure and what does it most often surface?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: So I designed the index with the intention to try to bring all this complexity that we’ve been talking about into an accessible first step exploration for organizations or someone in an organization to think about. These four lenses. So it is based on the four lenses of context. And there is a version that’s very quick and accessible, and I can share with listeners and of the show. But that’s a few questions, about four for each lens. So looking at lived insights and some prompts around that, systems thinking, personal agency, and shared vision. And each of the prompts are just kind of trying to synthesize you know, some of the cross-cutting themes I see across organizations, just to have someone respond to their read of their organization. So, for example, with personal agency, one prompt, and folks can reply and respond on a scale. The prompt is staff at all levels are encouraged to lead from their position, not just their title. So that is kind of just a quick cue to think about, okay, yeah, I think we, encourage staff to lead, or maybe not, or what so everyone, just kind of just a judgment interpretation for whoever’s taking the index. Like you’re pulling from something. So there’s something there. And again, this is like not like solving the organization. It’s just an introduction, a connection. And so ultimately someone will take this. And then what comes back is across those four dimensions, those lenses, it will let you know if the organization is activated. So that’s fully, like the untapped capacity is activated, is utilized. Again, from their interpretation, folks are. Working at their capacities or systems are working at their capacities. And then it goes down from there, So it could be emerging that there’s potential, but there’s maybe some areas of focus to kind of grow and you know close gaps. Or it could be as low as get underdeveloped or stalled. So really it’s just a chance to I don’t want to, I never want to flatten context, but I do need an entry point for folks to kind of just think about the questions posed, one, like the prompts posed, so that they kind of think about these lenses in these different ways and their work in those ways. But then come out the other end around, okay, maybe there is something that we need to do around agency. I don’t I really think now that we where our folks don’t have enough agency as I assumed.

Kevin Novak: So the one question I wanted to ask you, and it’s sort of a retrospective, and it relates to what you’re learning and seeing in the index. And so what has running it taught you that your book may have got incomplete?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Hmm. Yeah. You know, and it’s interesting because I wrote the book and then the work came after, to be honest, years of learning the book. In practice like in reality and I am always interested in operating in reality like what does that mean if I’m looking at all the indexes across the board and where folks are landing? Systems thinking is the usually comes back the lowest. And that’s consistent.

Kevin Novak: Which is surprising, isn’t it?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Which is surprising. But I’ll name that, the systems thinking prompts that I offer, they do have questions around power. And I don’t think we discuss power enough in organizations or, you know,

Kevin Novak: I agree with you completely.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: And so and just a real, you know, neutral investigation of power. Power carries so much stuff. With it. And again, and kind of thinking about, the human aspect of it. We either are holding power, resisting power, challenging power. Like, it just carry it’s not a neutral term at all. And but then how do we build we have to investigate it. And so I think that’s where people are not used to that.

Kevin Novak: Well, and I think I think people are afraid to talk about it. Like it’s like we react to it unconsciously. If someone is giving a power position, or based on a stereotype, we are, the social norms say we should do this or act a certain way in response. But time and again, in my own experience and I’m old. That no one wants to have that conversation and recognize that the influences of that, which is I always find so incredibly interesting.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: That’s right. And that’s right. And I think it’s, again, thinking about, you know, not to say the word a thousand times, but the context of power and the historical pieces of that. You know, I think again, I’ll use myself as an example. As I moved into positions of power in organization, I was uncomfortable with it. I didn’t I didn’t want it. And it took a while to explore what was happening. I thought I had I had built a discomfort with power, not itself. I had a discomfort with the misuse of power I had experienced at different levels of my career. And so that when I got very clear of like why am I uncomfortable with power, no, it’s not power itself. It’s when though that power has been misused and I’ve kind of experienced that. And so as much as we kind of dig into these conversations, the better. Again, we can kind of be clearer of how to lead, how to navigate, kind of that those challenges. But yeah.

Kevin Novak: Well yeah, because I mean that’s in some ways empathy. And I think in 2026 and forward that is a necessity for being a leader and using one’s it’s not soft skills per se, but to recognize that people are people and they’re not the widgets and they’re not on the assembly line. And again, I think it’s just so inbred in us. Right, it’s been taught to us in school, it’s been taught to us in leadership trainings of this is how you do this or that. And it’s time to change. Because I you know, even with AI here, right, the human humanity side of that is gonna remain important. And that may be how some leadership roles shift. And the recognition of the people and what makes them tick and how they react and just how to do things better. So I’ll I’m off my soapbox with that. I wanted to get back into measurement. So Robert Austin in a 1996 book called Measuring and Managing Performance in Organizations, and he built on Peter Blau’s definition of dysfunction. So consequences that move conditions in the direction opposite to stated objectives. So we’ve kind of touched on this with the wrong direction before. Austin’s emphasis is that dysfunction violates the spirit of what was intended rather than the letter. So people do not cheat. They optimize, honestly and visibly, for the thing that’s actually being counted. And the thing being counted quietly stops representing the thing that anyone actually cared about. So, an instrument that measures conditions is not immune to that. Right. The moment a leadership team watches a number about its own conditions, the conditions start performing. So the question here is how do you keep an index of the system from being becoming one more thing the system learns to produce? And Jenny, that really comes from in today’s terms, or I should say historically, because you really focus in on the history. Things were hard to measure. There were limited there was a limited set of things that could be measured to gauge performance or so forth. Now, with all of the data that’s produced and all the data that everyone has access to. Everyone is producing something and it’s so easy for an organization to fall back on a set or something power position why somebody promoted as why we measure this and why we should continue to. So how do you keep what you’re doing out of that becoming that structure for lack of a better word?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Hmm. Yeah, I mean, I think that’s a great question. I think so one piece is knowing that if we don’t measure then that’s its own problem. That we’re not looking at, paying attention to, valuing this measurement. Now what happens after that is, what that the interpretations of the measurements and the focal points and the questions that come and the, who’s again the what that how that informs decisions. If it doesn’t, I’ve seen again a like a little bit of a longitudinal trend folks will measure will like you know employee surveys and all these things and when and then nothing happens and so with the intention of the index is to surface and then the work comes from there the work is really around kind of the contextual integration of what we learned was surfaced. Because otherwise it then it won’t it won’t change or it won’t stick. It will be there and we’ll okay, that’s nice, but then but you know, where are the intervention points that we can point to in the work that comes from the measurement, but is not just only so dependent on the measurement. It now becomes its own thing.

SEGMENT 6: WHEN THE READING IS DONE BY AI

Kevin Novak: So one of the things that I’ve been bringing up is so we now have a lot of what you most of what you do or everything that you do is people focused, right? And it’s in the context of the systems thinking, the insights, so forth, and facilitating. And even the index has an output. In today’s terms, most organizations are turning to AI. Right, to read that data, to read that output and beget results, insights, and so forth from that. So where an organization has zeroed in and made something firm, what does the framework built on reading conditions do in an environment where the reading is increasingly done by something that cannot read? And in that regard, reading the room, right? And reading the nuances of that history.

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: The focus of the model, and just again, the highly contextual nature of humans that a machine will never ever be able to read. I find you know almost protection in the strong belief that you know being able to read context and adjust to it in the moment because it’s going to change tomorrow and it’s going to change from me to you. We’re building a practice that challenges the notion that AI can read an organization. AI can read, if you want to stay up there at a surface, it would be helpful. And so if there are organizations that are looking at that, so they might offer some insights at a certain level. I truly stand behind the durability of people and people being able to do this work. Themselves because that is going to be what makes an organization last. AI can be a tool. I don’t think it’s what’s gonna make an any organization, none of them, any of them last. And so I really stand behind it. When I work with teams, we look at the read the context, we take an action, and then we read the context again. Because something has changed. Once you do something, something has changed in the context. So then it this is like an ongoing exercise. And I think what is, unfortunately, very motivating with AI is the easier answers, is the easier thinking. And that’s what this work really challenges is that we’re I actually want to go into the mess so that we wrestle with it because then we will be better leaders as a result. And that’s hard.

SEGMENT 7: THE 48-HOUR DECISION AND THE REFLECTION

Kevin Novak: So, Jenny, that takes us to the question that I ask every guest towards the end. And I want to frame it around your around the constraint. So everything you described today takes time. It’s reading a system properly is slow. And the conditions under which a leader most needs an accurate reading are exactly the conditions that leave no room to get one. So a leader has 48 hours. A decision that can’t wait, no accurate reading of the conditions, and no way to get one in the time available. So what do you tell them? And is there such a thing as a minimum viable reading of a system?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: Yeah, and I think and this I love this question because again, this is reality for a lot of folks. That it this the 48 hour big consequential decision situation is common. I do think there is a minimum viable read when you just take a moment to consider the four lenses of the challenge. So who’s closest to the consequences? Who’s shaping the responses? What incentives or decision, what system elements are kind of when I make this choice, what’s going to happen in the system? Who’s left out? And how does this connect to our bigger vision? So there are these like core synthesizing questions that can be done fairly quickly. And that really is like the goal of this: is that we need to be agile because things are moving and changing all the time. So that agility. Can come from just taking a moment, just a pause, just a little pause to just be deliberate and intentional looking at these four lenses before making a decision. And then I think that’s the piece of it. Then learning from them what happens and this is the exercise. Then you can do it again, then you do it again, then you do it again. And so, my hope is when we’re thinking about contextual agility, yes, the opportunity I think we have is to spend time kind of bringing in context and we have that time and space. So that in the moments we don’t have that time and space, we’re starting from a stronger foundation. But if you haven’t done this work at all and you’re listening to this today, really kind of thinking about lived insights that are affecting this, the systems that are affecting this, who has agency in this, and then what is our shared vision in that? If you just spend a moment in that, I think it would offer a clearer decision path to try. So yeah.

Kevin Novak: That was so cool. And the last one. So after 25 years, 500 leaders and 200 organizations, what is one assumption you wish leaders would stop making about the people whose behavior they are trying to explain?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: My the one assumption I would have it is that the people experiencing it don’t have the answers. That the leader feels like they are the ones to solve that challenge when in fact those experiencing or that those behaviors, what and whatnot people have the answers. People equipped and are capable of naming how they can best work and how they can, you know, best bring their best selves. And usually that maybe includes some feedback up and around. But I think what I want to get away from is and I wrote about this in the book is kind of the leader as hero mentality and I am solving on behalf of others. And we need to stop that.

Kevin Novak: That’s profound. I’m gonna tell you that. I’m gonna make that a clip. Right out there. So Jenny, before we wrap, is there anything that you wanna leave the audience with? And where can people find you, the framework, and the book?

Jenny Vazquez-Newsum: I appreciate that. You know, I would really leave the audience with the hope that we when we’re looking at this complex moment and this kind of uncertain time, that we can do something about whatever it is we’re hoping to do. So really thinking about that. Shared vision, shared purpose, that future thinking. I don’t want us to lose our agency in thinking about within our realm, wherever that is, we have a choice and we can engage in this complex work. So if I were to kind of bring that all together, I it is really to just be hopeful and you know optimistic about the leadership of all of us. And you can find more about the work at untappedleaders.com. And the book Untapped Leadership: Harnessing the Power of Underrepresented Leaders is wherever books are sold, Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and anywhere there. So yeah, this was such a great conversation, Kevin. I appreciate you.

Kevin Novak: I agree, Jenny. I love this conversation. It was so enjoyable. Thank you so much for being on the Human Factor Podcast. I want to close by connecting what Jenny has shared to the arc of this season. We open Season 3 asking what organizations count, who decided, and whether anyone still has the standing to stop. Jenny has given us the question that comes one step earlier. Before you count anything, before you choose any intervention at all, who decided what the problem actually was? And what were they standing on when they decided it? Ross showed us that we reach for the person and we skip the situation. And that we don’t do it without noticing. Schein spent a career telling us that the most important assumptions in an organization are the ones nobody can articulate anymore. Leonard-Barton showed us that the rigidity is not the opposite of capability. It’s the same thing. Forrester through Meadows warned us that we usually find the leverage point and then push it to the wrong way. Collins, Weick, Sutcliffe, and Tangirala and Ramanujam all showed us the same thing from three directions. Accuracy and standing are distributed differently. And the organization that can’t tell them apart. Will keep mistaking its best information for its worst attitude. And Jenny, well, she’s built the method, not a better answer, but a way of finding out what you are actually looking at before you go looking for one. If there is an initiative in your organization right now that somebody has described as a resistance problem, the question to take into your next meeting is not how to overcome it. It is whether anyone in the room has read the conditions that will produce it, and whether the person who could tell you is someone this organization has taught to stay quiet. If you found today’s episode valuable, subscribe to the Human Factor Podcast wherever you watch or listen. Leave a rating and a comment and share this episode with your leadership team, especially with whoever gets to decide what the problem is. Subscribe to the Ideas and Innovations newsletter at 2040digital.com or on Substack for weekly frameworks and research on why change succeeds or fails. And connect with me on LinkedIn, where I post regularly about the psychology of transformation. Until next time, remember, it is never the technology, the market conditions, or the strategy that makes change and transformation successful. It’s the people. And the more deeply you understand the human factor, the more likely your transformation is to succeed. This is the Human Factor Podcast. I’m Kevin Novak. Thank you for watching or listening.

END OF EPISODE

Kevin Novak, Founder and CEO of 2040 Digital

Kevin Novak is the Founder & CEO of 2040 Digital, a professor of digital strategy and organizational transformation, and author of The Truth About Transformation. He is the creator of the Human Factor Method™, a framework that integrates psychology, identity, and behavior into how organizations navigate change. Kevin publishes the long-running Ideas & Innovations newsletter, hosts the Human Factor Podcast, and advises executives, associations, and global organizations on strategy, transformation, and the human dynamics that determine success or failure.