Understand How to Benchmark Your Digital Performance
Associations and non-profits often seek to benchmark their performance in digital against other associations. I would offer that it is better to seek benchmarks around the subject matter you represent and not compare your organization to other associations.
In today’s digital environment, content grows exponentially with many organizations, individuals and groups seeking to create authority and credibility.
Comparing Apples and Oranges
Those organizations, individuals and groups are publishing content on the same subjects and most likely trying to reach your members and greater marketplace.
As a result, it is more productive to seek out those who are competing for your members’ attention, understanding what they are sharing and how they are going about it. You may not be able to find “benchmarks” representing “competitor” performance but you can gather intelligence and compare your efforts, the performance of your efforts and determine what they are doing differently.
Digital Analytics, Benchmarks and “Content” Analytics
Focusing more on content and context analytic results can demonstrate to you how your subject matter based content is performing against others who publish similar or related content. The references may be B2B or B2C publishing organizations, bloggers, scientific communities or private company based (Medical Companies who publish a good amount of research as an example).
Everyone is dealing with information overload and over time develops a small group of resources to watch. As well, humans are different people throughout the day depending on what they are interacting with. A person may prefer printing a medical or scientifically focused document to read and not want to interact with the content online, that same person may seek out and watch a couple cat videos on the web and in the afternoon read work related documents on their computer or via the web. It is important to know what you member audience’s preferences are for your content and then set a baseline and a strategy.
Consumption VS Click
As a real world example, my own work with Medical Associations and Practitioners has shown that practitioners want summary focused content online that brings forth the major points they need to know. The content is quickly consumed in the short bursts of time they have available. As well the content should be structured to help solve an immediate need to help a patient or their families. Longer form content should be downloadable and printed for later consumption if there is ever time to read.
Consumption Amplification and Engagement
The benchmarks should focus on consumption, amplification and engagement again in context of the subject matter and recognizing the audience preferences.
I have a series of blog posts that attempt to demystify content analytics for editors, publishers and associations. They may help create understand how to create the right benchmarking and measurement strategy. I have two Content Analytic sessions coming up in Chicago and Los Angeles as a part of the American Business Media (ABM) Regional Education Series. Check out the great tracks and consider joining me.
Choose The Right Metrics
The team at 2040 Digital can help you identify the right benchmarks to create understanding of your organization’s performance in the digital realm. Contact Us.
Kevin Novak is the Founder & CEO of 2040 Digital, a professor of digital strategy and organizational transformation, and author of The Truth About Transformation. He is the creator of the Human Factor Method™, a framework that integrates psychology, identity, and behavior into how organizations navigate change. Kevin publishes the long-running Ideas & Innovations newsletter, hosts the Human Factor Podcast, and advises executives, associations, and global organizations on strategy, transformation, and the human dynamics that determine success or failure.
The Loyalty Trap – When Commitment Becomes a Cage Navigating the Psychology of Organizational Allegiance During Change and Transformation Issue 251, February 12, 2026 A senior vice president at a client I worked with recently described a moment that caused…
The Busyness Trap – Why We Wear Exhaustion as a Status Symbol Issue 250, February 5, 2026 Ask any professional how they are doing, and you are likely to hear some variation of “busy” or “slammed” or “crazy right now.”…
The Relationship Decay Rate – Why Professional Connections Atrophy Without Intention Issue 249, January 29, 2026 Someone you haven’t spoken with in three years reaches out asking for an introduction. You were once genuine colleagues, people who supported each…
When Being Right Isn’t Enough The Human Factor in Influence and Timing Issue 248, January 22, 2026 Early in my career, I watched a brilliant colleague present an analysis that was precise and correct. His data was impeccable, his logic…
The Confidence Calibration Problem Why Self-Assessment Fails Us at the Worst Possible Moments Issue 247, January 15, 2026 In virtually every meeting where decisions are being made, someone in the room is speaking with authority on a subject they understand…
The Advice We Never Take Why Leaders Seek Counsel They Systematically Ignore Issue 246, January 8, 2026 A CEO I worked with several years ago hired three different consulting firms over 18 months to advise on the same strategic question…